SIMPLE 401(k) plans have not really caught on. Employers interested in these plans generally opt for the very
similar–and even easier to administer–SIMPLE IRA plan. QACAs are new, and it’s not yet clear how well-received they’ll be. But safe harbor 401(k) plans (so called because they provide a “safe harbor” from the testing rules) have become quite popular since their introduction in 1999.
Everyone’s familiar with 401(k) plans. But not everyone knows they come in different flavors. There’s the traditional 401(k), of course. But there are also SIMPLE 401(k)s for small employers, 401(k)s with qualified automatic contribution arrangements (QACAs), and safe harbor 401(k)s.
The one thing all these special 401(k) plans have in common is that they’re generally simpler to maintain because they’re exempt from some or all of the complicated testing requirements that normally apply to traditional 401(k) plans. In order to qualify as a safe harbor plan, a 401(k) plan must meet special notice, contribution, vesting, and distribution requirements.
Special contribution requirements
In a traditional 401(k) plan you can, but you’re not required to, make employer contributions. In contrast, you must make a fully vested contribution to a safe harbor plan. You have several options. First, you can make a contribution of 3% (or more) of pay on behalf of each employee eligible to participate in the plan.
This “nonelective contribution” must be made even for participants who aren’t actively contributing.
Alternatively, you can match employee contributions to the plan. If you use this approach, you must match each employee’s contributions dollar for dollar up to 3% of that employee’s pay, and match contributions from 3% to 5% at a 50% rate (the “basic match”). You also have the option of making an “enhanced” matching contribution that’s at least as generous as the basic match, and that meets other requirements.
Your safe harbor contributions are generally subject to the same withdrawal rules that apply to employee 401(k) deferrals (that is, payouts are only allowed upon termination of employment, disability, death, hardship, or after age 59½).
Avoiding testing requirements
By using a safe harbor plan, you’ll automatically satisfy the “actual deferral percentage” (ADP) test that compares the average deferrals of your higher paid and lower paid employees. This test often limits the
amount that your higher paid employees can defer into the plan. If you make the basic safe harbor matching contribution, you’ll automatically satisfy the “actual contribution percentage” (ACP) test that applies to matching contributions. If you make additional matching contributions (including the enhanced match), you’ll avoid ACP testing if you don’t match employee contributions over 6% of pay, and any discretionary matching contributions don’t exceed 4% of pay. Finally, you’ll avoid top-heavy testing if you make only the safe harbor contribution to the plan.
Special notice provisions
You don’t have to use the safe harbor rules every year. But for any year you do want safe harbor treatment, you must provide a notice to employees at least 30 days before the plan year starts. The notice must tell employees you’ll be using the safe harbor rules for the following year, describe the safe harbor contribution you’ll make, and explain the employees’ rights and obligations under the plan. (Your formal 401(k) plan document must also include appropriate safe harbor language.)
You can also have a “flexible” safe harbor plan that lets you decide at year-end (instead of before the year starts) whether or not you’ll use the safe harbor rules for that year. But this option is available only if you’ll be making the 3% safe harbor contribution. You might find this plan design useful if you want to see how your discrimination testing is progressing before you commit to a safe harbor contribution for the year. You’ll still need to provide the notice to employees before the plan year starts, but the notice will tell employees that you may use the safe harbor rules for the following year. If you do decide to use the safe harbor rules, you’ll have to inform your employees by sending a second notice no later than 30 days before the end of the plan year.
QACAs
A QACA is a 401(k) plan with an automatic (“negative”) enrollment feature that avoids ADP, ACP,
A QACA may be an attractive alternative to a regular safe harbor plan if you like the idea of automatic enrollments.
and top-heavy testing that meets certain requirements. While most of the rules applicable to safe harbor plans also apply to QACAs, there are some notable exceptions. Under a QACA, an employee who fails to make an affirmative deferral election is automatically enrolled in the plan. An employee’s automatic contribution must be at least 3% for the first two calendar years of participation and then increase 1% each year until it reaches 6%. You can require an automatic contribution of as much as 10%. Employees can change their contribution rate, or stop contributing, at any time (and get a refund of their automatic contributions if they elect out within 90 days).
As with safe harbor plans, you’re required to make an employer contribution; either 3% of pay to each eligible employee, or a matching contribution, but the match is a little different–dollar for dollar up to 1% of pay, and 50% on additional contributions up to 6% of pay. You can also require two years of service before your contributions vest (compared to immediate vesting in a safe harbor plan). And if you select certain default investments to hold employees’ automatic contributions, you’ll generally be relieved of fiduciary responsibility for any losses your employees incur while in those investments.
SIMPLE 401(k) | Safe Harbor 401(k) | QACA | |
Which | All nongovernmental | All nongovernmental employers | All nongovernmental employers |
employers can | employers with no more | ||
adopt? | than 100 employees who | ||
earn $5,000 or more | |||
(must be only plan) | |||
Employee | Lesser of $12,500 or | Lesser of $18,000 or 100% of | Lesser of $18,000 or 100% of |
elective | 100% of compensation; | compensation; additional | compensation; additional |
contribution | additional $3,000 | $6,000 catch-up if age 50 or | $6,000 catch-up if age 50 or |
limit (2016) | catch-up if age 50 or | older | older |
older | |||
Required | -Dollar-for-dollar match | -Dollar-for-dollar match up to | -Dollar-for-dollar match up to |
employer | up to 3% of | 3% of compensation, 50% | 1% of compensation, 50% |
contribution | compensation OR | match above 3% to 5% | match above 1% to 6% |
(compensation limited to
$265,000 in 2016) |
2% of compensation to each eligible employee
-100% vested |
(enhanced match also available) OR
At least 3% of compensation to each eligible employee |
(enhanced match also available) OR
At least 3% of compensation to each eligible employee |
-100% vested | -100% vested after 2 years | ||
Discrimination testing | Exempt | Exempt from ADP test; exempt from ACP test if you make the safe harbor required contribution, don’t match contributions over 6% of pay, and limit discretionary match to 4% of pay | Exempt from ADP test; exempt from ACP test if you make the safe harbor required contribution, don’t match contributions over 6% of pay, and limit discretionary match to 4% of pay |
Top-heavy testing | Exempt | Exempt if employer contribution limited to safe harbor required contribution; otherwise required | Exempt if employer contribution limited to safe harbor required contribution; otherwise required |
Additional | No | Yes (discrimination testing may | Yes (discrimination testing may |
employer | be required); generally 3-year | be required); generally 3-year | |
contributions | cliff or 6-year graded vesting | cliff or 6-year graded vesting | |
permitted? |
Copyright 2006-
Broadridge Investor Communication Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.*Non-deposit investment products and services are offered through CUSO Financial Services, L.P. (“CFS”), a registered broker-dealer (Member FINRA/SIPC) and SEC Registered Investment Advisor. Products offered through CFS: are not NCUA/NCUSIF or otherwise federally insured, are not guarantees or obligations of the credit union, and may involve investment risk including possible loss of principal. Investment Representatives are registered through CFS. The Credit Union has contracted with CFS to make non-deposit investment products and services available to credit union members.
CFS representatives do not provide tax or legal guidance. For such guidance please consult with a qualified professional, information shown is for general illustration purposes and does not predict or depict the performance of any investment or strategy. Past performance does not guarantee future results.